This past week I continued my "classic movies I've never gotten around to seeing" project with Raging Bull and The Wild One. Plenty of ink has been given to both movies, so I think I'll try something hopefully more original and contrast the two of them.
Wild One, while a classic, is such a product of its time; its depiction of a motorcycle gang is such a 1950's whitewash, a group of mostly-harmless guys who are supposed to be threatening because they talk back to their elders and some of them have a five-o'-clock shadow. For God's sake, they cross-dress and dance in one scene. And while the camera work's great and the acting is adequate at worst and brilliant at best (I'd say Lee Marvin, not Marlon Brando, is the real highlight -- he's always drunken and violent! --; Brando just stands around acting like he's too cool for everybody, and in fact he's too cool for the silly movie he's in), the dialogue is some of the most ridiculous stuff I've ever heard. It's a Standards-and-Practices-inhibited Hollywood writer's interpretation of teenage slang; nobody ever really talked like that. Honestly I'd like to see it on RiffTrax -- sure, it's an all-time classic that spawned a genre and starred Brando, but is it really that much better than, say, Girls' Town or This Island Earth?
In fact, this seems to be the only movie where I've ever thought, "Hey, they should Rifftrax that," and then gone to their forum and NOT seen that a shitload of other people have already suggested it. I think I'm going to sign up for an account just to recommend it.
Anyway. As for Raging Bull, well, 35 years after The Wild One, Raging Bull's like a 180, real and raw and ugly. Where Wild One features "bad guys" who are way more likeable than the wholesome small-towners they terrorize, Raging Bull features a protagonist who's violent, crazed, and powerfully insecure, who alienates everyone who cares about him, including the audience.
Both classics, each starring one of the greatest actors to grace American cinema. Very different eras and approaches. One is quaint in hindsight; the other hits as hard now as when it was made. The Wild One is a lot more fun to watch, but Raging Bull is a way better movie.