Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[dtsund]

WELL THEN I GUESS I'LL VOTE FOR MISHA.

[Bongo Bill]

Misha was Luigi.

Night 3 begins. What will Mario do?

[Bongo Bill]

In the morning, Caithness is found dead. He was Bowser. The princess is now saved.

MARIO BROTHERS WIN

Cast of characters:
Bob Loblaw as Hammer Brother
Caithness as Bowser
dtsund as Koopa Troopa
Friday as Piranha Plant
gahitsu as Goomba
Grath as Lakitu
Kayma as Buzzy Beetle
Lottel as Mario
Misha as Luigi
Special thanks to Classic

THANK YOU SO NICE FOR TO PLAYING MY GAME.

How do you feel about this? This is still an experimental ruleset and all comments are valuable.

[Grath]

I hate not being able to scheme behind people's backs.

[Caithness]

Was my asking where the number 3 came from what gave it away?

[dtsund]

Was my asking where the number 3 came from what gave it away?

Might've been, I know I facepalmed when I saw that post.  I spent the rest of the day trying as hard as I could to make you look bad in the hopes the Bros. would consider you a poor kill target.

[Misha]

I like the "assassination" style of the game but I think it gives koopas a bit too little to do? Might be better with more roles.

[dtsund]

Also, did Lottel just quit playing?  The two of you had every opportunity to votebomb myself or Bob Loblaw toward the end.

Speaking of Bob Loblaw, how was Classic not a plumber?  I was convinced that he hadn't noticed Friday's vote change and legitimately thought he was casting the penultimate vote on Bowser, which, needless to say, would be a really stupid thing for someone in the Koopa Troop to do.

[Bongo Bill]

Lottel delivered a kill order on Caithness in a timely manner, so I know he didn't just drop out, but I don't know what anybody was thinking at any time, and invite y'all to share.

[Misha]

Lottel was paying not a ton of attention, and also thought you guys were disorganized enough to not need to votebomb

[Lottel]

I was paying plenty of attention, thankyouverymuch.
I just didn't post a lot. Quite a difference, you know.

As for kill order, it didn't really matter. Like Misha said, I didn't feel the town to be incredibly organized and a leisurely culling of the town is a bit more fun for the everyone involved than a swift execution. Not a huge rush to gnab the Bowser.

[gahitsu]

It felt really disorganized, yeah. I don't think Bronto's metagame is equipped to handle a game without PMs. 

[Caithness]

My plan to use the vote-chain to reveal a Brother seemed to work pretty well, but then of course we couldn't just vote for Misha right off the bat like that. But Misha and Friday seemed to be always voting together, so I decided to attack indirectly by voting for Friday. When she voted for me back it kind of messed up my plan, but also made me 100% sure she was the other Brother.

[Caithness]

Also of course the Koopa Troop was unorganized. PMs were disallowed, and any attempt to organize in-thread runs a huge risk of revealing Bowser's identity.

Perhaps it would be better if only Bowser wasn't allowed to send PMs?

[gahitsu]

Also of course the Koopa Troop was unorganized. PMs were disallowed, and any attempt to organize in-thread runs a huge risk of revealing Bowser's identity.

Perhaps it would be better if only Bowser wasn't allowed to send PMs?

No, it'd still be bad. Either we weren't told, or I skimmed the fact, that we weren't allowed to PM people during this game, but my original plan, should I end up as either Bowser or a Koopa Trooper, was to PM everyone and ask who Bowser was. Whoever answered incorrectly was going to be publicly shamed and lynched.

[Grath]

Also of course the Koopa Troop was unorganized. PMs were disallowed, and any attempt to organize in-thread runs a huge risk of revealing Bowser's identity.

Perhaps it would be better if only Bowser wasn't allowed to send PMs?

No, it'd still be bad. Either we weren't told, or I skimmed the fact, that we weren't allowed to PM people during this game, but my original plan, should I end up as either Bowser or a Koopa Trooper, was to PM everyone and ask who Bowser was. Whoever answered incorrectly was going to be publicly shamed and lynched.

To which I would've said "and why do you want to know, gahitsu?"

[dtsund]

Also of course the Koopa Troop was unorganized. PMs were disallowed, and any attempt to organize in-thread runs a huge risk of revealing Bowser's identity.

Perhaps it would be better if only Bowser wasn't allowed to send PMs?

No, it'd still be bad. Either we weren't told, or I skimmed the fact, that we weren't allowed to PM people during this game, but my original plan, should I end up as either Bowser or a Koopa Trooper, was to PM everyone and ask who Bowser was. Whoever answered incorrectly was going to be publicly shamed and lynched.

To which I would've said "and why do you want to know, gahitsu?"

Pretty much that.

[Grath]

Also, even if PMs were allowed but Bowser couldn't PM - If Bowser can receive PMs (which he'd have to, since you could PM people), you have everyone in the Koopa Troop PM Bowser with some form of obfuscation scheme (IE first letter of each sentence, I'll throw around four joke votes first day and the Marios are 2 and 3, etc). You now know who the Marios, but this information can only be said publicly. So you do some form of voting chain like we did this game and whoever Bowser votes for in the vote chain is the person whose obfuscation scheme has been used.

[Kayma]

I died.