Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

1. Megaman 2

9 (64.3%)

2. Castlevania 3: Dracula's Curse

5 (35.7%)

Total Members Voted: 14

Voting closed: September 24, 2012, 09:11:08 PM

[Friday]

LoZ and Metroid move on. So long, Tetris.

Next:

59. Adventure Island 2
12. Crystalis
24. Life Force
51. Blades of Steel

The wind is filled with sorrow. Return to Leaf soon.

[Büge]

We need a hockey game to move forward!

[Kayma]

Blades of Steel was actually pretty great! Doesn't compete with Lifeforce or Crystalis though.

[Friday]

Adventure Island 2 barely edges out Life Force by 1 vote, moving on with Crystalis.

Next up:

33. Excitebike
21. TMNT 2
13. Ninja Gaiden
63. Super Dodge Ball

The far superior TMNT NES game goes up against some stiff competition.

[Brentai]

It says something about TMNT2 that what we can agree is a "far superior NES game" is really kind of a far inferior arcade port.

Well, I mean, I guess it only really says something about the arcade game.

[Büge]

Nobody else liked Excitebike?

[Rico]

Holy shit I broke a four-way tie.

[Niku]

My hatred of Ninja Gaiden for the Xbox is thankfully not retroactive.

[Friday]

Ninja Gaiden and Super Dodge Ball both are well ahead of the others.

Next up:

52. Ice Hockey
8. Megaman 3
44. Maniac Mansion
37. Duck Hunt

This is the final round of 64.

[Rico]

Gah. Have to go with Maniac Mansion, as it's even got better graphics and music than the original version. Megaman 3 is exceptional but Megaman 2 was slightly better. Duck Hunt was Duck Hunt. WHAT IS MY SECOND CHOICE?

[Beat Bandit]

And so we have the first round with a game I actually played on the console.

[Rico]

Purple Tentacle will slay the infidels.

[Friday]

In an extremely close three way race, MM3 and Duck Hunt win 11 and 10 over Maniac Mansion's 9.

Starting round of 32.

[Friday]

1. *** The Legend of Zelda
2. Zelda 2: Adventure of Link
3. *** Super Mario Bros
4. *** Super Mario Bros 2
5. *** Super Mario Bros 3
6. Megaman
7. *** Megaman 2
8. *** Megaman 3
9. Dragon Warrior
10. Dragon Warrior 3
11. *** Bionic Commando
12. *** Crystalis
13. *** Ninja Gaiden
14. Ninja Gaiden 2
15. *** Castlevania
16. *** Castlevania 3: Dracula's Curse
17. *** Final Fantasy
18. *** River City Ransom
19. Tetris
20. *** Shadowgate
21. TMNT 2
22. *** Contra
23. *** Dragon Warrior 4
24. Life Force
25. Gradius
26. Batman
27. *** Kirby's Adventure
28. Metal Gear
29. *** Bubble Bobble
30. Blaster Master
31. Battletoads
32. Kid Icarus
33. Excitebike
34. *** Duck Tales
35. *** Punch Out
36. *** Metroid
37. *** Duck Hunt
38. Willow
39. *** Double Dragon
40. Journey to Silius
41. *** Little Nemo
42. *** Wizards and Warriors
43. Kung Fu
44. Maniac Mansion
45. *** Super C
46. *** Rygar
47. Rad Racer
48. Ghosts 'N Goblins
49. Adventures of Lolo 3
50. Dr. Mario
51. Blades of Steel
52. Ice Hockey
53. Metal Storm
54. Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles
55. Jackal
56. Faxanadu
57. *** StarTropics
58. *** Marble Madness
59. *** Adventure Island 2
60. R.C. Pro-Am
61. *** Guardian Legend
62. Clash at Demonhead
63. *** Super Dodge Ball
64. Xexyz

All the Mario games advance, but Zelda 2 and Megaman 1 are eliminated. Two of the four submission games are eliminated. The list for Ro32 ends up being:

1. The Legend of Zelda
2. Super Mario Bros
3. Super Mario Bros 2
4. Super Mario Bros 3
5. Megaman 2
6. Megaman 3
7. Bionic Commando
8. Crystalis
9. Ninja Gaiden
10. Castlevania
11. Castlevania 3: Dracula's Curse
12. Final Fantasy
13. River City Ransom
14. Shadowgate
15. Contra
16. Dragon Warrior 4
17. Kirby's Adventure
18. Bubble Bobble
19. Duck Tales
20. Punch Out
21. Metroid
22. Duck Hunt
23. Double Dragon
24. Little Nemo
25. Wizards and Warriors
26. Super C
27. Rygar
28. StarTropics
29. Marble Madness
30. Adventure Island 2
31. Guardian Legend
32. Super Dodge Ball

[Friday]

We'll keep the format the same for Ro32. Two threads, four options, two votes.

First match:

16. Dragon Warrior 4
7. Bionic Commando
24. Little Nemo
6. Megaman 3

[Büge]

Dragons and Commandos!

[Friday]

Bionic Commando leads, but a tie between DW4 and MM3 forces me to do my first tiebreaker of the tourney. In the end, though I love both games almost equally, I decide to go with DW4 because it's the only DW still in the running.

Next up:

2. Super Mario Bros
25. Wizards and Warriors
3. Super Mario Bros 2
20. Punch Out

[Niku]

I VOTE FOR THE GAME THAT MAKES MY HEART GO DOKI DOKI

and also punch out

[Friday]

We have a tie for second place between SMB2 and Punch Out, but unlike the other thread this is an easy tiebreaker for me. While I love SMB2, Punch Out gets the nod, making it advance with the original Mario.

Next up:

27. Rygar
28. StarTropics
31. Guardian Legend
21. Metroid

[Büge]

Gotta give it to the girls.