Ignoring when kayma became shaved, this would mean events went as follows:
Day 1: I shave caithness, a murderous bastard, we lynch poor envy.
Night 1: classic/caithness kill nex
Day 2: I shave classic, we lynch caithness, a murderious bastard
night 2: Kayma, a scrying wolf (may or may not have been shaved) dies.
day 3: ardus is an unshaved scryer, classic is a shaved killer
One more issue arrises looking at the timeline. why did classic rip out kayma's thoat? Why did classic just make it so terribly obvious that he is a killer? What reason do I have for not shaving ardus right now and ending the game if my theory is true? Discuss.
There is one major problem with your theory. Dont the wolves win when they outnumber the innos? If there were 4 wolves out of 8 original players, the innos would have lost when we lynched Envy. It suggests that there are probably 3 wolves, not 4. On top of that, I still see no point in time where he wouldve been shaved.
I like your theory that I am a wolf. However, I am no such thing. About the only thing you shaved was my beard and mustache. They were getting a little long anyway!
I think that Kayma is pulling your leg. If I were a dead wolf who can still win with the wolves and someone had the power to talk to me, I would relay false reports to influence the lynch vote towards someone who I know is an innocent. That way the wolves would still win! I wouldnt put it past Kayma to be sneaky enough to do that. However, there is also the possibility that Kayma wasnt dead when he spoke with Classic. None of us but the Cap'n knows the order of night actions. If we assume that Kayma WAS a scryer and contacted Classic before his death, it would definitely support the idea that Classic is a wolf. In a match where the innocents arent supposed to contact each other at night, why and how would a wolf have the power to contact an innocent?
He (Kayma) claimed that a shaven wolf only counts for an innocent victory, not desire an innocent victory.
Classic, why are you working for an innocent victory as a shaved wolf if this is true? It really seems like either YOU are distorting the information that Kayma is giving you, or that Kayma is distorting information and you arent reading it closely enough. I do agree that this is probably the last chance for an innocent victory and I wouldnt want us to make the wrong choice.
He claimed that he had no knowledge of Lottel.
I believe Lottel is the final wolf. It really seems like Kayma is stringing classic along. Based on Classics actions and the information he is relaying from Kayma, I assume Kayma was the wolf who knew another wolf from the start. Placing the spotlight on me could be the perfect way to direct attention away from his real wolf buddy, Lottel.
Lottel, you must be taken out if the crew is to survive.
Sorry for the long reply. I have been kinda busy with housekeeping, preparing for classes, and actually going to classes. The semester started yesterday.