Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Kayma]

ps: my money is still on kayma / glados

Just so we're clear, Kayma and Glados are different people.

[NexAdruin]

NexAdruin - 6
Falselogic - 8
Nickasummers - 2
Kayma - 4
GLaDOS - 13
Lottel - 4
Envy - 2
fullmooninu - 3

this is what I've got for postcount, though I could be off. there are a lot of lurkers.

[NexAdruin]

Also I counted consecutive posts as multiple posts which maybe I shouldn't have done, and I added together Guild's various accounts as one.

[Lottel]

ps: my money is still on kayma / glados

Just so we're clear, Kayma and Glados are different people.

OR ARE THEY?

[Nickasummers]

Well, I just went through the entire day and took hard notes, and am ready to issue my thoughts on everyone

Envy - quiet and hasn't contributed anything. He needs to talk more, but given the fact that I haven't had much to say yet either, I can sort of understand. No Idea

Falselogic - starts out dismissive, which is exactly how you should react to early accusations, but then when the second vote hits him he immediately becomes very defensive. Later he makes a typo and fixes it in under a minute, which looks very hasty to me. Eventually he stops being defensive and just drops a sarcastic comment that doesnt help his case at all. Probably a wolf.

Fullmooninu - has yet to contribute anything of value to the discussion, but did manage to slide the word "vanilla" into a post even though nobody has even suggested he might maybe possibly be a wolf. suspicious

GlaDOS - Predictable as ever, he is looking at people and changing votes without rhyme or reason. I actually appreciate this sort of behavior because it gets many people talking and sees who ignores it an who responds to it, but it hasn't done much this game. no idea

Kayma - heavy on the "kill falselogic" train right from the start. Could have some information already. In fact, pretty much everything he has said this game can be restated as "kill falselogic do it now!". Oddly violent, but seems to bold to be a wolf. inno, oracle?

Lottel - Has made multple mistakes and hasn't contributed much. correct me if i am wrong, but I dont think he has actually voted yet, despite acting suspicious of false. I also don't remember him giving any compelling reason why he didn't vote for false. He seems VERY fishy to me at this point. possible wolf

NexAdruin - accused by glados and never even addressed it. Suggests a level head, and a good move on his part. Jumps on the bandwagon before it even becomes one, and as glados explained, made a very safe vote. Having played, watched, and discussed wolf games with nex, it seems very possible to me that he is a wolf that is doing a good job of hiding it. Possible wolf

[Lottel]

Nicka, we've played enough games together for you to know how I don't vote unless I'm fairly sure. And then it takes a lot for me to change the vote.
I don't have enough to vote and feel good about it.

[NexAdruin]

Lottel - Has made multple mistakes and hasn't contributed much. correct me if i am wrong, but I dont think he has actually voted yet, despite acting suspicious of false. I also don't remember him giving any compelling reason why he didn't vote for false. He seems VERY fishy to me at this point. possible wolf

I don't know what you mean by making mistakes, but everything in bold applies to you as well.

[Nickasummers]

I also don't remember him giving any compelling reason why he didn't vote for false.

Nicka, we've played enough games together for you to know how I don't vote unless I'm fairly sure. And then it takes a lot for me to change the vote.
I don't have enough to vote and feel good about it.

The way you presented that feels off to me, but you have now given your reason and I will give you credit for that.

Lottel - Has made multple mistakes and hasn't contributed much. correct me if i am wrong, but I dont think he has actually voted yet, despite acting suspicious of false. I also don't remember him giving any compelling reason why he didn't vote for false. He seems VERY fishy to me at this point. possible wolf

I don't know what you mean by making mistakes, but everything in bold applies to you as well.

He has misread and miswritten, which is probably meaningless but it does show a degree of carelessness
I know I haven't contributed much, I'll admit that, I don't know what to say yet.
I know I haven't voted yet, and the reason is because, as you can see, I have listed multiple people as possible wolves and I am trying to determine who is most likely to be a wolf.
The fishyness of lottel I cannot explain, because I dont know why he seems fishy to me. I also dont know what seems fishy about me to you, other than the things addressed above, so if you can explain that feel free to.

[NexAdruin]

You just laid out a list of all the people you think are wolfy, and one of them stuck out as "probably a wolf" while the others were "no idea, prob inno oracle, and possible wolf" yet you haven't voted. Don't you want to kill scum? Don't you want to see the wolves hang?

[Nickasummers]

I would love to see them hang. "Probably a wolf" and "possible wolf" are descriptions of how likely i think each is to be a wolf based on facts. The thing is, I have a bad feeling about Lottel, and my intuition hasn't been horrible in past games. I didn't want to go all-out on the falselogic kill while my gut was still telling me Lottel, a guy leaning toward that kill, is a wolf. That said, Lottel hasn't actually jumped on that bandwagon yet. Which means if he is a wolf, he probably thinks logic is too and he wants to look inno but doesn't want to kill his ally.

Falselogic, but I am keeping my eye on Lottel.

[the asshole you hate]

Nickasummers is making a lot of noise.

Lottel's been a wolf in like... EVERY GAME this year, so I really am totally making a balls out bet that he's not one now even though everything that is logical inside me is against it and I normally never would factor successive odds into my assessement for any reason.

You're a smelly old wolf, nicka.

[Caithness]

falselogic - 3 (Kayma, NexAdruin, Nickasummers)
GLaDOS - 1 (fullmooninu)
Nickasummers - 1 (GLaDOS)

[NexAdruin]

Let's stop dicking around and lynch this scum.

[Kayma]

Kayma - heavy on the "kill falselogic" train right from the start. Could have some information already. In fact, pretty much everything he has said this game can be restated as "kill falselogic do it now!". Oddly violent, but seems to bold to be a wolf. inno, oracle?

Don't you think publicly pontificating about me being the oracle paints something of a target on my face? That's wolfy, man. Mad wolfy.

[Nickasummers]

Your first post was "this guy is a wolf kill him" your second was "wooooooooolf". If the wolves didn't notice that, we have nothing to worry about.  Given that, noting that you are more likely oracle than wolf means falselogic is a safer bet than he might otherwise have been and you are more likely inno. The baner, assuming there is one, will likely protect you, and probably would have anyway because, again, oracle is the obvious conclusion based on the facts.

[Lottel]

Kind of a leap from "He's calling someone a wolf" to "He's the oracle."

[NexAdruin]

Idea: let's lynch falselogic and find out if Kayma's a power role!

[Kayma]

I dunno. Nicka is acting wolfy enough that I think it wouldn't be a bad idea to gamble on lynching him today, and saving False as a "sure thing lynch" tomorrow. I'm cool either way though.

[fullmooninu]

i asked a question i shouldnt have asked?

cause i got no answer...

[Nickasummers]

I have a question: how come we don't even know how many wolfs are there?

We often are not told exactly how many, and in this case lots of things are secret (we usually know all of the roles in play, just not who has them)