buddy, if you want crazy, here's some crazy for you:
My belief that Stush wasn't the PI was based around the fact that he didn't say anything about Friend's second role as the Devil—I assumed the PI would have no reason to conceal that, as long as he was still aligned with the innocents, and so I didn't want to tip my hand to Stush (who I honestly thought was evil at the time) by showing that I knew Friend was the Devil.
Fuck it, I'll vote Friend, if I can.
Here's a reason stush would conceal the fact that I'm the devil: because he wanted to protect his identity. Probably from werewolves or in your case, vampires. See, here's my theory. Newbie and Stush are actually both vampires conspiring to lynch me. Stush may or may not be the PI, but if he is, he's a turned PI. The fact that he confessed that he was the PI didn't change anything in Newbie's case. He said he didn't want to tip his hand to Stush, but for some reason he does so now. Stush didn't do anything to prove that he was the PI. All he did was confess it, after Newbie basically set him up to do so:
The fact that Stush wants to kill Friend intrigues me, because I know for a fact that Friend is the weretiger: the PI accepted my bid to scry him last night. I wouldn't be admitting this right now, but since Friend is getting votes, that's enough reason to suspect at least one evil team is aware of his felinity.
The PI accepts Newbie's bid, everyone votes for Stush, and now Stush happens to be the PI? Another thing: look how Newbie talks about how I was getting votes. In fact, the only vote on me was Stush's vote. Certainly reason to suspect at least one evil team was aware of my felinity, right? Because of one vote? It's not like you're a vampire bringing up my weretiger status to get me lynched, right?
The fact that Newbie tried to divert the attention away from Stush by bringing up my weretiger status and then subsequently giving Stush an opening to claim PI, while changing his vote from Stush to me, leaves me thinking that Newbie is a vampire mastermind. One last thing:
I don't think we should vote Friend, since the wolfpires will be falling all over each other to kill him now.
Fuck it, I'll vote Friend, if I can.
I mean cmon, even if you're innocent and you think Stush is the PI, at least look for another bad guy, not the one you acknowledge would be a poor lynch.
ANYWAYS
if you're talking bizarre scenarios, I figure I'd at least get that one out of my head.